A long-serving BBC presenter has lost his unfair dismissal claim after being sacked for branding a fellow host “sociopathic” in a dispute over comments on Hamas.
Sean McGinty, who worked for BBC Radio Lancashire for over two decades, was dismissed following posts on X in which he criticised the BBC’s coverage of the conflict in the Middle East on social media.
In an email to BBC 5Live host Nihal Arthanayake, Mr McGinty called him “sociopathic” and made references to convicted murderers Harold Shipman and Lucy Letby.
Mr McGinty, who suffers from ADHD and severe anxiety, argued his actions were a result of his conditions and brought a discrimination case against the broadcaster.
However, the tribunal found his claims were “not well-founded”.
The presenter, who was 63 at the time of his dismissal, had been a broadcast journalist, presenter, and producer at BBC Radio Lancashire since September 2006, with a total of 22 years as a reporter.
It was noted that he had not informed one of his managers about his ADHD diagnosis.
Following the October 2023 Hamas attacks in Israel, Mr McGinty was critical of the BBC and the way it reported on the attack.
The BBC Policy for personal social media use at the time read that staff were not “prohibited from using social media platforms in a personal capacity”.
“The BBC’s reputation for impartiality and objectivity is however crucial,” it said.
“Staff should take reasonable steps to ensure their activity on social media does not undermine the BBC’s nor their own, professional impartiality or reputation and/or bring the organisation into disrepute.”
Mr McGinty posted numerous times on X regarding subjects including Hamas and expressing anti-trans views.
Mr McGinty later emailed Mr Arthanavake – who recently quit 5Live – and his production team under the subject heading ‘Nihal’s contextualising Murders Book Club’.
The email read: “I felt I ought to step offline and take some time (a week is just enough) to consider how to express my thoughts on your tweet below…”
“It is remarkable that you have the hubris to instruct me to read a book so I can find out why these animals are such murderous bastards…these are actions of evil monsters…It’s sociopathic of you to suggest anyone should read a book to seek context…I don’t look for context for disgusting excuses for human beings.
“That being said, I am looking forward to your recommending books that give some context and understanding of Lucy Letby, Harold Shipman and the Yorkshire ripper. I hear Stalin had a terrible childhood. You should do your own book club.”
He was later moved to a BBC sounds role but was not happy and believed the “reorganisation was destroying the BBC”.
Mr McGinty continued to post on X about the conflict in the Middle East and transgender issues, saying that Jewish people were being “forced to leave Israel”.
An investigation began and he took the posts down, saying that he was “under a great deal of stress and anxiety because again BBC bosses are having a pop at me when it is the talent that is the problem”.
He went on long-term sick leave in November 2023.
He was due to return to work in January 2024 but did not turn up, despite being called by colleagues.
In February 2024 he put up more posts criticising the BBC, saying it should “hang your head in shame”.
In April 2024 he contacted his boss and told him about his ADHD diagnosis, which led to an occupational health report which found him unfit for work.
He was later taken to a disciplinary hearing for his social media posts and was sacked for gross misconduct in July 2024.
During the proceedings he posted on X saying: “I am about to get sacked by the BBC for gross misconduct for stating biological and journalistic truths.”
He later appealed the decision, saying that his behaviour changed because of his mental health condition, but it was unsuccessful.
It was found that his actions constituted a “failure to adhere to the expected standards regarding impartiality and respect in your public discourse, and your failure to seek the necessary approval before writing publicly about the BBC in your blogs”.
Mr McGinty brought claims of disability discrimination, failure to make reasonable adjustments and unfair dismissal to the employment tribunal in Liverpool.
His claims were all unsuccessful and dismissed.
Employment Judge Dawn Shottey said: “The Tribunal found there was no causal connection between his disability and the gross misconduct Mr McGinty was accused of.
“[Mr McGinty] says he has a right to hold his views and there is no disputing that he indeed had this right.
“The problem for [Mr McGinty] was communicating his views to the wider public in breach of fundamental constraints imposed on him given the fact he was employed as a journalist and subjected to policies, which if breached, could result in disciplinary proceedings and dismissal.
“The Tribunal found on the balance of probabilities [the BBC] otherwise acted in a procedurally fair manner and the dismissal fell well within the range of reasonable responses.
“The Tribunal found that contemporaneous documents support this analysis, including [Mr McGinty’s] deliberate attempt to circumvent managerial control by failing to inform higher management and the press office of his proposed communications before they were made public because he knew that “they would say no”.
“Objectively assessed, such behaviour cannot fall under the definition of impulsivity, and for [Mr McGinty] to limit his posts so that they can be read by his followers alone (and not viewed by [the BBC]) suggested calculated conduct and not impulsive behaviour.”
