Hammersmith and Fulham Council rejected the Phoenix Academy proposal at a committee meeting in April
The Mayor of London Sir Sadiq Khan is set to decide on controversial plans to redevelop a West London school after the scheme was refused by the local authority.
Hammersmith and Fulham Council rejected a proposal back in April to knock down the Phoenix Academy by White City and rebuild it alongside 307 homes.
The proposed redevelopment, filed by applicants Future Academies and London Square, would have affected the site’s western collection of buildings, which the school has described as “outdated, underused and unsafe”.
Under the scheme four new education blocks up to four storeys tall and six residential, up to eight storeys, were to be built. Of the 307 homes planned, 90 were to be affordable, all of which would have been for social rent.
The scheme had however drawn substantial local opposition with a petition organised by the Wormholt Residents Association (WRA) drawing 718 signatures. During consultation the council received 60 representations in favour, with 34 against.
At the council’s Planning and Development Control Committee meeting Mark Smith, Development Director at London Square, said: “These proposals represent the best chance our school has of securing the more than £40 million that we need to make improvements to the academy.
“Members will be fully aware that these costs are spiralling upwards each month, linked to inflation, and we do not have the luxury of a wait and see approach when it comes to the future of the education that our children deserve.”
Councillors voted to reject the application due to concerns about its scale and consultation with the community.
The proposal has however been given a second lease of life after the Mayor chose to call it in, meaning he, or more likely his Deputy Mayor for Planning, Regeneration and the Fire Service, Jules Pipe, will determine it themselves.
A public hearing is to be held at City Hall ahead of any decision being made, at which parties including the council and the applicant will be asked to submit evidence. No dates for the hearing are currently listed on the Greater London Authority (GLA) website.
Julian Vallis, a local resident and Treasurer at the WRA, accused the applicants of bypassing local democracy “to force a mayoral call-in”.
He said: “While the GLA has intervened, in failing to notify us it has also failed itself in its assessment which fundamentally misrepresents and misunderstands the case.
“The design is profoundly problematic. How both LBHF [London Borough of Hammersmith and Fulham] and the GLA can categorise a development plunging 259 existing homes into darkness to build 307 new ones—a net gain of just 48 well-lit properties—as causing “less than substantial harm” to the Conservation Area is incomprehensible.
“This scheme is devoid of ambition, offers no new infrastructure, and ignores adjacent developments and provides only a marginal benefit of a ‘better’ school—not a new school or anything additive to the community.”
Mr Vallis said that while the WRA is “angry and disappointed” with the outcome it is not unexpected.
“In this David and Goliath battle, we remain as motivated as ever,” he said.
“We’re working in tandem with our MPs, ward councillors, and neighbouring residents’ associations to mount a robust defence of our community and beautiful Conservation Area against this unworkable monstrosity of an application and put forward our much more ambitious and comprehensive masterplan for the area to reverse 50 years of chronic under investment in the area.”
Both Future Academies and a spokesperson for the Mayor said they cannot comment at this stage.
Don’t miss out on the biggest West London news. Sign up to our MyWestLondon newsletter HERE for all the latest daily news and more.
