By the evening of Saturday, 3 March, the families of the three young women “were so worried that they decided to report them missing to Gwent Police”, having been unable to contact them for hours and noting their lack of presence on social media
Ross’s mother, Claire Ross, and Russon’s father, Nathan Russon, went to Newport central police station to report their children missing.
The panel was told logs were created at this time which would help with subsequent enquiries.
During this time, Smith’s mother, Emma Borg, had gone to the caravan the young people had travelled to and found her daughter’s handbag there but no sign of the group.
Morley told the hearing that the “people in the caravan weren’t particularly helpful”, making Smith’s mother realise that “something was very wrong”.
Smith was eventually reported missing by her sister Lauren Doyle a couple of hours later, which included “sensitive information” adding overall to what was described as a “very worrying set of circumstances”.
He added that the force also received “some concerning information about the men that was added to the system” which he said he would not read out in public.
The hearing was told that PC Hardwick and PC Livingstone were on a 16:00 to 03:00 shift and were given the “straightforward task of attending two home addresses to take any details from family members and to search”.
Morley said this was something that “should always happen” during a missing person’s enquiry and was “common sense” – allowing officers to assess whether the missing person might actually be at home, might have left something of importance behind like a note or might have taken something of importance.
The panel heard PC Livingstone had been assigned the search of Smith’s house and PC Hardwick that of Russon’s, but the two officers went to both addresses together and when they returned filled in the relevant paperwork.
PC Livingstone said she had first spoken to Smith’s brother and then her mother.
In relation to the search, the following was written down: “Nothing missing out of the usual.
“Mum and Dad was concerned and Mum believed she went out in the same clothes and has not taken any new clothes with her.”
That, the panel were told, was a “dishonest and misleading entry”.











