Harry Scoffin, the founder of Free Leaseholders, claimed existing leaseholders in London will see little help as a result of the changes
London’s leaseholders are being let down by cautious Labour ministers who refuse to stand up to wealthy freeholders, a housing campaigner has claimed.
The feudal-era system sees so-called ‘homeowners’ purchase the right to live in a property for a fixed number of years, but never to own the land itself.
London’s disproportionate number of leasehold flats means that the capital is “uniquely exposed” to the problems associated with the tenure – an admission made by Housing Minister Matthew Pennycook last year.
The capital has 1.44 million leasehold dwellings, which accounts for about 39 per cent of the city’s total housing stock, according to the most recent data released by the Government.
However, almost a decade on from the previous Conservative Government starting the process of reforming leasehold, millions of leaseholders continue to face uncapped service charges and limited control over their buildings.
On Thursday (November 19) the Government unveiled the landmark Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill which will cap ground rents, stop new leasehold homes being built and make it easier for current owners to convert their tenure into commonhold. It still needs to pass through both chambers in the Houses of Parliament in order to become law.
But Mr Pennycook, who has been in charge of enacting the Labour Party’s promise to abolish leasehold once and for all, has now been accused of “dragging his heels” due to pressure from freeholders with deep pockets – some of whom are suing the Government over the leasehold reforms being introduced.
Freeholder pressure
“It’s the big money interests, the people that own these freeholds and [collect] ground rents,” Harry Scoffin, the founder of Free Leaseholders, told the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS).
“The freeholders are claiming that their human rights are being breached.
“This is a huge story – but Labour have only recently started to switch on the legislation because of the campaigning and the publicity of leaseholders not being able to sell their homes.
“Every time parties come into power, they leave it to the last minute, they water down the reforms, and basically then they hope that the next government will be left to basically sort it out. So they always kick the can down the road.”
WATCH THE FULL INTERVIEW WITH HARRY SCOFFIN NOW
He accused Mr Pennycook of making “everything about consultations and being technical”, adding: “He’s not necessarily someone who can be a rule breaker and actually ram through change.”
The Ministry for Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) would dispute this view, with officials previously stating that uprooting a 1,000-year-old system needs to be done carefully and methodically to avoid any future legal or logistical issues.
Mr Pennycook has also pointed to flaws in the previous Conservative Government’s Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024, claiming Labour needed to lay down primary legislation to resolve certain problems.
An MHCLG spokesperson told the LDRS that they “completely reject” Mr Scoffin’s account, adding: “The Housing Minister introduced the historic Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill to Parliament [on Thursday], which is the biggest changes to homeownership in a century, and is delivering the most sweeping changes to land and property law in a generation.
“The changes he is driving through mark the beginning of the end for the feudal leasehold system, and will make homeownership fairer and give people the freedom to truly own their property forever.”
But the bill does very little for leaseholders in London and beyond, Mr Scoffin has claimed.
“Labour promised to end leasehold for good, but instead is creating a disastrous two-tier system: shiny new commonholds that everyone will want to snap up, and leasehold legacy homes facing continuing boycotts, plummeting values and no meaningful escape routes,” he said. “This Bill is a stinker – don’t fall for the spin.”
Slow progress on leasehold is also disrupting the capital’s struggling housing market. Fears over service charges – which will still be uncapped, even after the new law is passed – is putting off prospective buyers, forcing leaseholders to sell at a loss.
Hamptons analysis of Land Registry data for 2025 found that flats made up 60 per cent of London property sales but accounted for 90 per cent of loss-making transactions in the capital – up from 78.4 per cent in 2019). Overall, 14.8% of all London sellers made a loss in 2025 – the highest share of any UK region.
Breaking point
MPs – especially London representatives – have held the Government’s feet to the fire over leasehold for years. Brent West MP Barry Gardiner welcomed the new bill but said that the capital had been waiting for the legislation for three decades.
Abena Oppong-Asare, Chair of the Housing, Communities and Local Government (HCLG) Committee and a London MP, added: “Leaseholders have been waiting far too long for successive governments to tackle the unfair leasehold system. It is now vital the Government does all it can to ensure this legislation makes a timely passage through Parliament and that we use this opportunity to get the reforms right for leaseholders.”
Sir Sadiq Khan has also raised his concerns in City Hall frequently – though Mr Scoffin suggested he was letting his Labour colleagues off softly.
“Even if the Mayor has limited powers to actually get the ball rolling, what he could do is use his advocacy skills nationally to hold the Government to account. He could do a lot more, and I think that’s where we’re going to see in two years’ time [at the 2028 Mayoral election] whether candidates vying to replace him are going to be silent.
“This is the last chance for Labour. Candidates cannot swerve this issue.”
A spokesperson for the Mayor of London responded: “The Mayor has consistently stood up for leaseholders by campaigning to end the feudal leasehold system once and for all.
“He welcomes the draft legislation the Government has introduced into Parliament, to replace leasehold with commonhold tenures, which matches systems used across most of the world. He has already asked every housing delivery organisation in the GLA family to prepare for commonhold now, ensuring Londoners begin to see the benefits as soon as the legislation comes into force.”
Watch every episode of The London Brief as soon as it’s released by subscribing to MyLondon’s YouTube channel











